
It's hard to put into words how much a part of the fabric of our town the Haymaker Farmers' Market is - though we've tried. Casey, in a post about our weekly visits to the market, called it "The ritual that nourishes us." In referring to the market as the "soul of a city," I noted that the market represents what's truly best about people and Kent itself. Further, I've been fortunate enough to design the day-of-market signage for a former vendor and, in a fit of late-night energy, even tried my hand at a quick redesign of the market's identity.
All of this is just a longer way of saying how much we love the market - and how much it means to us. Imagine our excitement, then, when new market manager Kelly Ferry approached us earlier this summer with the proposition of completing a proper redesign of the Haymaker identity! What you see above is the result of that process, but before I go into more detail about the identity we're so proud of, let's look at what it replaced and Ferry's goals for the redesign. The old logo:

Initially, when Kelly approached us, she was interested in strengthening the previous logo and turning it into a true branding element she could use on things like the web, t-shirts, re-usable bags, signage, collateral and, potentially, permanent pole banners near the market's location. The old logo was hard to incorporate into new pieces, so she was also interested in adding some sort of frame to the identity to bring everything together.
We, meanwhile, were interested in cleaning up several things we noticed about the logo, including the mixed case of the title, the thin white outlines around the crops and the notion that you didn't get a sense of heritage from it. The market is one of the oldest in the state - next year will be its 20th anniversary - and we felt it merited a refreshing that spoke to the twin senses of tradition and optimism surrounding both the market and the city it calls home. It was also imperative to me to deliver a final product that could look good in multiple colorways and when reproduced at any size, large or small. In the end, we arrived at six logos total, representing three distinct descriptors and two unique colorways. The first pair:

Almost immediately, we knew we wanted to go in a completely new direction with regard to the agricultural product depicted. Both the beans and tomato were appropriate, but to us the apple - green in one colorway and red in the other - spoke to the kind of American optimism we wanted the new logo to express. When approaching us, Ferry expressed interest in having an enclosure around the final product as well as incorporating the depiction of a field within. The twist, from our end, came in deciding to make the apple the focal point (like the sun in the Great Seal of the State of Ohio) with the "field" emanating from the apple like the rays of the sun. The second pair:

Once we knew we wanted the apple/field and sun/rays to be the focal point within the enclosure, the decision of how to treat the market name itself came easy. We placed it within a below-center banner that appears to wrap around the enclosure, coming from behind on the left and disappearing again on the right. The darker color of the banner in both colorways places emphasis on the name but never takes away from the importance of the apple. In the above options - interchangeable with the first pair - we replaced the "Kent, Ohio" with "Since 1992." The descriptors ended up fitting just right within the space created by removing some of the rays and that is bounded by both the enclosure and banner. The third and final pair:

The above options, of course, promise to be a focal point of next year's market collateral. Twenty years is an impressive milestone for a market that is only gaining steam, so it's something to be quite proud of. It should be noted that we also thought it very important to not have too much descriptive detail within a relative confined space. This is why there are three distinct options as opposed to trying to jam the city, founding date and anniversary into one mark.
A logo can't be all things to all people, or else you risk losing the simplicity that makes the best marks so memorable. What's more, most people won't spend nearly as long looking at the logo as the designer or client, so you have to be sure to avoid bombarding the viewer with too much information. And finally, what if the logo ends up on a poster with a bunch of others and therefore gets reproduced at a very small size? The more descriptors, the harder that miniature logo will be to read.
As for the chosen typeface for the final product, we used House Industries' Neutraface, which I've been in love with since its release. Neutraface perfectly encapsulates the tradition, optimism and progressivism we hoped to express in the logo. And since there are so many varieties of apples - just as there are so many wonderful offerings at the market - we presented each logo option in two separate colorways. Why don't we refer to them as the Granny Smith or Braeburn options?
When I've discussed logo projects in the past on this site, I've been careful to include options that either didn't make the final cut or were stops along the way. I'd like to do so again here. The first logo you see below is, again, the one I designed as a late-night what-if. It offers both a green color scheme and sense of mid-20th Century optimism that, in some ways, made it through to the final product. Below that are two looks at a logo that fully emphasizes the field over any crop at all - and creates an "H" icon out of individual plots in an overhead patchwork of fields. A decent logo, but lacking the energy of the eventual winner.

We couldn't be happier with these new logos - or how well the design process went in working with Kelly. She's just the leader the market needs as it transitions into its next phase and we hope that its new look helps keep the positive momentum going. The Haymaker Farmers' Market is so important to not only Casey and I, but also to the city we love. To be able to have a hand in branding such a prominent fixture in your community is a tremendous opportunity, and one that we approached with gusto. I hope you enjoy the result as much as we do.
